8 mins to read

When to Convert a Contractor to a Full-Time Employee

Table of Contents


Effectively juggling your workforce is quite the balancing act. Independent contractors are often responsible for handling specific needs in your company. 

Over time, a considerable portion of these contractors reveal themselves as indispensable assets, seamlessly becoming an integral part of your organization, thus aligning with your company's goals, and making a profound impact on your business's success.

These individuals stand out and seem like they'd fit right into your full-time team. They've got the skills, and the commitment, and they're on the same page with your company's values. Plus, they're raring to grow with your organization. 

This has led you to the point where you must decide – is converting contractors to employees the right decision, or should you keep them as freelancers? It's a big decision that can affect many aspects of your regular business operations.

But don't worry, we're here to help. In this blog, we'll shine a light on the signs you should look out for when deciding to convert your contractor to a full-time employee. We'll give you the lowdown on the perfect timing for a contractor to full-time conversion to make a wise, well-grounded decision about where your workforce is heading.

From local labor laws and compliance with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), to communicating change to your freelance international contractors, establishing a plan for employee benefits and more, read on!

1. Your Contract With Them Is Nearing Its End

You've been working with a contractor for a considerable duration, and now, the end of the contract is drawing near. It's a pivotal moment, one that demands careful consideration and strategic planning. As you stand at the crossroads, you're faced with two primary options: renew the contract or transition them into a full-time employee.

Converting a contractor to full-time holds the potential to significantly impact the future of your workforce and your organization as a whole.

As you find yourself at the juncture of contract renewal, take a moment to reflect on the long-term implications of your decision rather than rushing into it. 

Benefits a Full-Time Employee Can Provide

While renewing a contract may seem like a straightforward solution, transitioning the contractor into a full-time employee can provide your organization with the following benefits:

  • Stability
  • Enhanced integration
  • Skill retention
  • Cost-efficiency

It will not only break the cycle of contract renewals but also position your company for sustainable growth and success. 

When the time comes, it’s vital to make the choice that not only serves your immediate needs but also strengthens your organization's foundation for the future.

2. You End Up Re-Hiring An Independent Contractor Multiple Times

Let’s say you’ve decided to hire a talented designer from Canada for a three-month project. You take a brief two-week break and then engage their services again, this time for eight months. The pattern repeats – you take intermittent breaks, and the cycle continues. 

While the flexibility may seem advantageous, you find yourself revisiting the same resource for their expertise over and over.

This raises an essential question: Is this cycle truly an optimal situation for your business? As we explore this scenario, consider the long-term implications and financial benefits of making the transition from repeated contract hires to full-time employment.

The cycle of rehiring a contractor multiple times, punctuated by short breaks, can appear convenient. 

However, failing to transition those contractors into full-time employees can come with its own set of downsides. For one, you might miss out on the opportunity to nurture and retain top talent. 

When these valuable contributors remain as contractors, there's a risk they might seek more stable opportunities elsewhere, leaving your organization at a loss. 

Moreover, the lack of continuity in your workforce can disrupt project flow and hinder long-term planning. In a nutshell, not making the shift to full-time employment can lead to the loss of key talent, potential disruptions, and a less cohesive team, which may negatively impact the overall success and sustainability of your business.

Timing is crucial when considering the transition from repeated contract hires to full-time employment. The financial considerations, talent leverage, risk of discontinuity, and long-term benefits suggest that transitioning to full-time employment can be a strategically sound decision. 

It's also important to consider that independent contractors handle their personal taxes. This often means that they will charge a little extra for their services to cover those costs. If you are continuously hiring the same contractor, it may help you to save money over time - since they will no longer have to consider this factor.

By making this shift, you not only convey your commitment to the individual's talent but also set your organization on a path toward stability, productivity, and sustained growth. When the time comes, make the choice that aligns with your organization's long-term vision and nurtures the talent that drives your success.

3. Your Business Is Highly Dependent on Their Services

From the outset, we emphasized the valuable role that individual contractors play as extensions of your team. Some of these dedicated contributors wield a profound influence, perhaps even bearing the core responsibilities of your business. 

In such a scenario, your enterprise finds itself with an enviable asset—exceptional expertise at its disposal. However, this advantageous position also brings with it a conundrum: relying heavily on an individual contractor who bears no commitment to your business's long-term success.

It's a reality worth considering. While individual contributors provide invaluable services, their allegiance often lies beyond your organization. They are, fundamentally, service providers, not business owners or employees. That distinction is pivotal. While they deliver expertise and aid your business in numerous ways, they don't possess the same level of ownership and devotion that an employee can provide.

When converting from contractor to full-time employee, salary, work hours, as well as the overall transition process are indeed intricate aspects to consider. Nevertheless, the strategic shift away from heavy reliance on individual contractors to full-time employment pays off in the long haul. 

It aligns your business with the coveted benefits of reliability, commitment, shared vision, and skill retention that full-time employees bring. While individual contributors are undoubtedly valuable, recognizing the need for a deeper level of commitment and ownership in certain areas of your business can elevate your organization to new heights. 

So, as you navigate this path of converting a contractor to an employee, remember that the decision you make today can position your business for enviable success in the long run.

4. You Want to Absorb This Talent Within Your Workforce

Every so often, you encounter an individual whose talents and contributions to your endeavours are nothing short of exceptional. They bring that extra spark, that unique edge, and that irreplaceable value to your projects. In such moments, it becomes evident that you are dealing with someone who possesses a calibre of talent that could significantly enrich your workforce and give you a competitive advantage.

Exceptional talent is like a rare gem, highly sought after and coveted by many, including your competitors. The prospect of losing this extraordinary individual to another company or, worse yet, to a direct rival is a scenario most organizations would rather avoid.

In the realm of talent management, recognizing and embracing exceptional contributors is a strategic move. Their invaluable expertise, creativity, reliability, and commitment can be transformative for your organization. 

While exceptional talents are sought after, the decision to bring them on board as full-time team members can secure your access to their remarkable skills and dedication. 

It's a choice that ensures stability, shared vision, seamless integration, and skill retention for your business, fortifying your position in the competitive business landscape. 

So, as you navigate the path of talent acquisition, remember that the decision you make today can position your organization for enviable success in the future.

5. You’d Like This Contractor to Exclusively Work for You

The desire to have a contractor work exclusively for your organization may initially seem like an unusual aspiration. After all, the very nature of a contractor's role is defined by their flexible and non-permanent engagement with a company. However, in certain situations, the unique relationship that develops between a contractor and an organization over months or years can lead to a compelling case for exclusivity.

This case is not rooted in the contractor becoming a part of the conventional employment structure but rather in the remarkable alignment that has evolved. It's about culture, shared values, and a profound integration into the organization's ethos despite not being an official employee. When faced with such a scenario, the logical and enviable step is to transition this contractor into a permanent employee.

6. You Ended Up With an Unfortunate Misclassification

The complexities and nuances of classification can often lead to unfortunate missteps. Misclassifying an independent contractor as a full-time employee is a scenario that no organization anticipates or desires. In instances like this, it becomes essential for employers to convert their contractors to full-time employees.

Yet, when it occurs, the urgency to rectify the situation becomes paramount. The ideal moment to make this conversion was yesterday, and the implications extend far beyond borders, as local laws around the world can be unforgiving when it comes to the misclassification of employees.

The unintentional misclassification of an independent contractor as a full-time employee is a situation that demands immediate attention and correction. The legal, financial, and reputational implications of misclassification underscore the urgency of converting misclassified contractors into full-time employees. 

This move not only ensures compliance with labor laws but also fosters employee satisfaction, trust, and organizational reputation. So, as you navigate this path of rectification, remember that the decision you make today can significantly impact the future of your organization and your global standing in the world of employment.

7. You Want to Better Protect Your Company’s IP With Full-Time Employees

The importance of safeguarding intellectual property (IP) cannot be overstated. Your IP is the lifeblood of your organization, representing your innovations, competitive edge, and proprietary knowledge. It's the embodiment of your business's unique identity and value in the marketplace. 

However, when IP is involved, the stakes are high, and ensuring its protection is a strategic imperative.

When you engage independent contractors, it's important to recognize that they operate with a certain degree of autonomy. Unlike full-time employees who are bound by a myriad of legal protections, independent contractors are often governed solely by the terms of their contract. 

This difference in legal standing can present a significant risk to your company's IP. One misstep, one inadvertent disclosure, and the delicate fabric of your intellectual property can be jeopardized.

Safeguarding your company's intellectual property is a strategic imperative in the competitive business landscape. When sensitive IP is involved, transitioning contractors with access to this knowledge into full-time employees is a prudent move. It not only offers legal protection but also enhances security, ethical alignment, and long-term commitment to the protection of your IP. 

In the dynamic world of modern business, ensuring the security and integrity of your intellectual property is an enviable goal that positions your organization for long-term success and innovation. So, as you navigate the path of IP protection, remember that the decision you make today can significantly impact the future of your business.

Empower Your Remote Independent Contractors with Borderless

You've successfully identified the pivotal signs that indicate it's time to transition your remote contractor into a full-fledged employee. Now, it's time to explore the most convenient path to make this transformation a reality. That's where Borderless steps in – your trusted Employer of Record (EOR) platform, simplifying the process of hiring, compensating, and nurturing new team members, regardless of their geographical location.

With Borderless, you can focus on your core business goals, scaling, and expanding, while we take care of the essential paperwork and the employee experience. Let's delve into how our platform streamlines this transition:

Streamlined Employee Details

Simply provide us with the necessary employee details. Based on the specific country of employment, we tailor our services to your unique requirements, covering everything from background checks to misclassification checks, ensuring compliance and peace of mind.

Tailored Local Employment Contracts

Borderless specializes in creating local employment contracts that meet and exceed compliance standards, customized for your specific needs. These contracts are prepared, reviewed, and ready for your employee's signature.

Smooth Commencement and Salary Disbursement

The journey from contractor to employee is remarkably straightforward. Once your employee has inked their contract, they seamlessly transition into our system, becoming eligible for regular salary payments. From this point on, you can engage with them just like any other valued member of your team.

Effortless Oversight with Borderless

Our user-friendly dashboard provides you with a comprehensive overview of all employee information, from contractual details to salary disbursements and beyond. This transparency extends to your employees, empowering them with the same insights. Managing changes and ensuring a seamless experience has never been more effortless.

Borderless simplifies the often complex process of transitioning contractors into full-time employees, allowing you to navigate this transformation with ease and confidence. Your business can embrace growth and expansion with the assurance that the essentials are being handled efficiently. 

Join the ranks of businesses that have harnessed the convenience and effectiveness of Borderless. Make the transition today, and empower your remote contractors to become integral members of your thriving team.

Disclaimer: Borderless does not provide legal services or legal advice to anyone. This includes customers, contractors, employees, partners, and the general public. We are not lawyers or paralegals. Please read our full disclaimer here.


Ready to hire anywhere in minutes?
Back to Blog